Church Leadership
Meet Our Team
REV. PAUL HEMENWAY
Senior Pastor
Pastor Hemenway is new to Holy Trinity. He joined our staff on August 1st, 2024. He leads our congregation in worship, provides member care and supports our ministry staff in any way he can.
REV. JOSHUA BRAKHAGE
Associate Pastor
Pastor Brakhage leads Holy Trinity’s Discipleship Hour ministry (Sunday school), small group ministry, and member care. He has a passion for people and would love to connect with you.
A.J. CLUCK
Executive Director
A.J. supports the pastoral staff by managing the daily operations of the church.
BECCA CRAWFORD
Director of Communications
Becca is the face behind all communication for our church and school. She manages Holy Trinity’s websites, photography, videography and social media while also creating graphics and print pieces.
CHRISTOPHER EVATT
Director of Parish Music
Dr. Christopher Evatt provides our congregation with both music and the opportunity to create music. He fills our Sanctuary with organ music on Sunday mornings, and also leads several music groups including our Sanctuary Choir, and Handbell Choir.
TOBY YOUNG
Director of Youth & Family Ministry
Toby leads our youth program, directs our children’s ministry and is working to expand and grow family ministry at Holy Trinity.
molly baxter
Office Manager
Molly is the first face you will see when you enter our facility on a week day! Molly answers our main phone line, manages our main email account, assists pastors with scheduling meetings, and helps with other various administrative work, including membership documents.
MICHELLE MORTON
Ministry Coordinator
Michelle joined our team November 2025! She schedules Sunday volunteers, creates ministry action teams, gets new members plugged in and plans our church events.
LUKE DEARDOFF
Media Ministry Developer
Luke assists our Director of Communications with video and audio content for services, social media and more. He is also the point person handling our IT and tech equipment throughout the building.
JEFF NEMCOK
Head of School
Jeff joined our team in July of 2025 and brings a level of excellence and excitement to our school. His goal is to lead our church’s largest mission in growth and excellence. Jeff is also in charge of supplying curriculum and overseeing accrediation.
RACHEL TROWBRIDGE
School Principal
Rachel leads the church’s largest mission, our Preschool through 8th grade day school and our Mother’s Day Out program in day to day operations.
Robert Smith
School Assistant Principal
Robert assists Rachel is school operations and oversees Holy Trinity Lutheran Schools athletics and extracurricular programs.
STEWART PRINCE
Director of Facilities
Stewart is responsible for keeping our facility in proper working order – both inside and out.
JEFF KING
Business Manager
Jeff works closely with our Executive Director and School Director to reconcile and manage church and school finances.
TONY WHITE
Head of Security
Tony works tirelessly to monitor our church and school to ensure the safety of our students and staff. He oversees a volunteer campus security team as well.
STACI PICKENS
Custodian & Computer Tech
Staci works hard to keep our facility clean and organized. In addition, Staci assists with technology support on our campus.
AUSTIN WOOD
Custodian
Austin works diligently to keep our campus clean and assists our Director of Facilities in various projects around campus.
Gordon Wagoner
Head Elder
Bill Kuehn
Elder
Steve Kukuk
Elder
Ron Allie
Elder
Kyle Young
Elder
Randy Williams
Elder
Jim lowry
Elder
michael sloup
Elder
Allen nance
Elder
Jeff Noyes
Elder
Elders Not Pictured
Tom Roel
Leadership Board
Congregational President: Scott Waugh
Vice President: Julie Luster
Treasurer: Gary Prestegord
Secretary: Bethany Ford
Head Elder: Gordon Wagoner
School Board Chair: Nicole Warehiime
Members at Large:
Joe Beck
Mark Sisco
Ken Loeber